Skip to main content
Canada-wide · FSRA #13737

Private lender vs bank:
which mortgage route
fits your situation?

Choose a bank when you qualify — lowest rate, longest term. Choose a private lender when a bank says no: equity-based, fast, and flexible. Always treat it as a bridge with a clear exit plan back.

What's the Difference

Four factors that
separate them.

The right choice almost always comes down to whether you qualify at a bank right now — and how urgently you need to move.

Qualification

How they qualify you

A bank leads with your credit score and provable income under strict federal rules. A private lender leads with your home's equity — its value, marketability, and the loan-to-value. If there's meaningful equity and a credible plan, a private lender can approve files a bank won't touch.

Speed

How fast each moves

Banks work in weeks: underwriting, appraisals, and federal regulatory checkboxes take time. Private lenders can often fund in days once appraisal and a lawyer are ready. That speed gap is exactly why private lending exists for urgent closes.

Cost

Rate, fees, and the real cost

A bank offers the lowest rate available — the reward for fitting its strict criteria. A private mortgage carries a higher rate plus lender and broker fees, disclosed in writing before you commit. The cost reflects the added risk the lender takes with less documentation.

Term strategy

Short bridge vs long runway

Banks offer long terms — five-year fixed is the classic Canadian mortgage. Private lenders are short-term by design, commonly one year. A private mortgage is meant to solve a specific problem and then be refinanced back to a bank, not held permanently.

How to Choose

Three steps to
the right decision.

For most people, a bank is the goal.
Private is the bridge when the goal isn't reachable right now.

01

Understand your situation

Do you qualify at a bank right now — strong credit, provable income, standard property? If yes, that's almost always the cheaper route. If not, identify what's blocking you: bruised credit, complex income, tight timeline, CRA arrears. The blocker determines your path.

02

Compare on the factors that matter

Rate alone doesn't tell the whole story. Compare the total cost — rate plus fees, over the actual term you'll need — against what a bank or B-lender would cost if they could approve you. We price both side by side before you commit to either.

03

Get pre-approved with an exit plan

If private is the right tool today, define the exit before you sign: repair credit, document income, resolve arrears, or sell. With 100+ lenders, we map both the bridge and the way back to lower-cost financing — all in writing under FSRA #13737.

Which Is Right for You

Find your situation below.

Tap any scenario to see the recommended route and why.

If you’re…

Strong credit, salaried job, no rush

Bank / A-lender

You fit the rulebook, so take the cheapest money. A broker still shops multiple A-lenders so one application gets you the best available rate and term without any of the private-lending premium.

Start my application
If you’re…

Declined by the bank last week

Private bridge with exit

A decline usually means one lender's rules, not a dead end. A private bridge can fund now while you repair the issue and refinance back to a bank — often inside 12 to 24 months.

Explore my options
If you’re…

Purchase must close in five days

Private lender

When a bank can't move fast enough, an equity-based private lender often can fund in days — buying you the close with a plan to refinance afterward once the urgency is gone.

Get funded fast
If you’re…

Self-employed with income hard to document

Price both routes first

A B-lender may still work at a meaningfully lower cost than private. A broker prices both against your equity and timeline before you decide — sometimes the right answer is B-tier, not private.

Price my options
If you’re…

CRA tax arrears or back taxes owed

Private bridge

Most A-lenders and many B-lenders will not advance past CRA liens. A private lender can often fund a refinance that clears the arrears at closing, stopping interest and penalties — then you work toward a bank once CRA is satisfied.

Clear my arrears
If you’re…

Bruised credit, rebuilding over the next year

Private now, bank in 12–18 months

A private mortgage buys time to repair your bureau without losing the property or missing the purchase. With a clear credit-rebuild plan and a defined exit date, the higher short-term cost often beats the alternative of no mortgage at all.

Map my exit plan
Side-by-Side

Bank vs private —
every factor compared.

The right answer depends on what's blocking you. The table shows the real trade-offs on every dimension.

Bank / A-lender — best for

The lowest-rate, longest-term option for borrowers who meet strict credit, income and property criteria under federal lending rules.

  • ✓You have strong, provable income and good credit
  • ✓Your property is standard and easy to appraise
  • ✓You want the lowest rate and a long term
  • ✓You have time — no urgent closing pressure
Private lender — best for

An equity-based lender that qualifies mainly on your home's value. Fast and flexible when a bank says no — at a higher rate, with fees, on a short term.

  • ✓You've been declined by a bank or B-lender
  • ✓You're self-employed or have complex income
  • ✓You need to close in days, not weeks
  • ✓You need a short-term bridge with an exit plan
Private lender vs bank comparison by qualification, rate, fees, speed, flexibility, term, purpose, and stress test
FactorBank / A-lenderPrivate lender
What they qualify onCredit + provable income (+ property)Home equity (property value first)
RateLowest availableHigher — reflects the added risk
FeesMinimalLender + broker fees, disclosed upfront
Speed to fundWeeksOften days once appraisal and lawyer are ready (not guaranteed)
Flexibility on income/creditStrict — federal rules applyFlexible — case-by-case on equity
Typical termLong (e.g. 5-year terms)Short — commonly around a year
Best used asYour long-term mortgageA short-term bridge with an exit
Stress testYes for federally regulated lenders (OSFI B-20)Generally not applied the same way
The honest verdict
Bank if you qualify. Private if you don't — with a defined exit back.
A broker prices both and maps the exit before you commit — not after.
Price both for me
FAQ

Common questions,
clear answers.

Qualification, cost, speed, approval — answered plainly.

What's the difference between a private lender and a bank?

A bank (A-lender) qualifies you mainly on credit and provable income under strict federal rules, and offers the lowest rates on long terms — but it's slower and declines files that don't fit. A private lender qualifies mainly on your home's equity, so it can fund bruised-credit, complex-income, tax-arrears or urgent files a bank won't. The trade-off is a higher rate, lender and broker fees, and a short term. For most people a bank is the goal and private is a short-term bridge.

Is a private mortgage more expensive than a bank mortgage?

Yes — a private mortgage carries a higher rate than a bank, plus lender and broker fees, because the lender takes on more risk with less documentation. We don't publish a fixed rate because it depends on your equity, property and file. The key is that it's short-term: judged as a bridge that unlocks something a bank couldn't, the cost is often worth it. A good broker discloses every fee in writing before you commit.

When should I use a private lender instead of a bank?

When a bank won't work right now: you've been declined, you're self-employed with income that's hard to document, your credit is bruised, you have CRA tax arrears, or you need to close in days rather than weeks. In those cases a private lender's equity-based approval can bridge the gap. If you do qualify at a bank or B-lender, that's almost always the cheaper route, so it's worth pricing both first.

How does a private lender decide whether to approve me?

A private lender leads with your property rather than your income and credit. It looks at how much equity you hold, the home's value and marketability, and the loan-to-value you're asking for. If there's meaningful equity and a credible plan to repay or refinance, it can approve files a bank would decline. Income and credit still matter to the exit plan, but they aren't the gatekeeper the way they are at a bank.

How long does a private mortgage last?

Private mortgage terms are short — commonly around a year, versus the longer terms a bank offers. That's by design: a private mortgage is meant to solve a specific, time-limited problem and then be replaced, not to be your permanent mortgage. Before you sign, you should have a clear exit — refinancing back to a bank, documenting income, resolving arrears, or selling — so the short term works in your favour.

Can a broker help me choose between a private lender and a bank?

Yes — that's exactly where a broker adds value. With access to 100+ lenders including banks, B-lenders and private lenders, a broker can price both routes side by side, tell you honestly whether a lower-cost option might still approve you before reaching for private, and map the exit back to a bank. Under FSRA licence #13737, all rates and fees are disclosed in writing upfront, so you decide with the real numbers in front of you.

The Mortgage Squad Guarantee

We’ll try to beat your rate.
If we can’t, we pay you $500.¹

¹ Rate Beat: eligible Big-6 bank written offers only · same product, term & amount · $500 paid to you or your nominated charity at closing · conditions apply

Find a mortgage specialist in your city

Whether you need a bank mortgage or a private lending bridge, our FSRA-licensed advisors serve every major market in Canada. Rates, lender access, and the full side-by-side comparison are the same from coast to coast.