Skip to main content
Mortgage Squad Advisors
Case studyConsumer proposal Whitby, ON· Refinance · Early payout · Private

Paid off a consumer proposal early with home equity — compressed a 5-year term

One year into a five-year proposal, a homeowner with strong equity refinanced to settle the proposal in full, completing it early and accelerating the return to prime pricing.

Client
Homeowner ~1 year into a 5-year consumer proposal, strong home equity
Situation
Four years of proposal payments remaining; wanted to end it and rebuild faster
Goal
Settle the proposal now and shorten the road back to A-lender pricing
The challenge

The proposal had four years to run. Each of those years meant premium (non-prime) pricing on any financing and a delayed return to A-lender eligibility.

The client had ample home equity but no lump sum of cash — so the question was whether the cost of tapping equity was worth the time it would save.

What we did

We modelled the payout math carefully: home value, existing first mortgage, the amount to settle the proposal in full through the trustee, and fees — confirming the refinance would leave a healthy equity cushion rather than drain it.

Because the proposal was still active at funding, we arranged a private second mortgage sized to settle it. The proceeds went to the trustee, the proposal completed, and the discharge clock started immediately — compressing a four-year runway into the time it took to close. We set the exit to refinance into A pricing once credit seasons.

The outcome
Home value
$780,000
First mortgage
$410,000
Proposal payout
~$32,000
Private second (incl. fees)
~$50,000 (~59% combined LTV)*
Term compressed
~4 years → months
Exit plan
Refinance to A as credit seasons

Settling early started the discharge clock years ahead of schedule. The premium on the short private second was modest next to four more years of non-prime pricing — and it was only pursued because the equity was ample enough to keep a strong cushion. On a thinner-equity file, the honest advice would have been to wait.

The takeaway

With ample equity, paying a consumer proposal out early can compress the whole recovery timeline. It only makes sense when the math works and it doesn't drain your equity — which is exactly why the numbers get modelled before anyone commits.

Illustrative case study. Details are representative of the types of files Mortgage Squad Advisors funds and have been anonymized — no client names or identifying information are shown. Rates, products, and approvals depend on your individual situation and lender criteria at the time of application. Figures reflect 2026 market conditions and are examples, not guarantees of outcome.

In a similar situation?

Every file is different — but the playbook is the same: the right lender, structured properly. Tell us your situation and we'll map your options. Free, no credit pull to start.

FAQ

Common questions

Can you pay off a consumer proposal with home equity?
Yes, if you own a home with enough equity. You refinance (through a B-lender or private lender, since the proposal is active at funding) and the proceeds settle the proposal in full through your trustee. It completes early, starting the discharge clock and shortening your path to A-lender pricing — but only makes sense when the payout leaves a sensible equity cushion.
Is paying off a proposal early always worth it?
No. It's worth it when you have ample equity, you're early in a long proposal, and your credit is already rebuilding. It's often not worth it if the payout would drain most of your equity, you're near the end anyway, or credit rebuild — not the proposal itself — is your real bottleneck.
Meet Maya

Canada’s 24/7 AI mortgage advisor.

Have a question right now? Maya answers instantly — in 50+ languages. Real humans on every file. Best-rate guarantee, or we pay you $500 — yours or your charity’s.

  • Instant answers
  • 50+ languages
  • Instant payment math
  • Voice calls
M
Maya · AI advisor
Typing…