The same Winnipeg house, two closing days
Take Winnipeg's $439,216 average detached home price and change nothing but the buyer's status.
More detail
A permanent resident puts $21,961 down (5% — 5% of the first $500,000 and 10% of the rest), finances a 4.00% default-insurance premium of $16,690 into the mortgage, and brings $31,545 to the lawyer once you add $6,434 of land transfer and registration cost, no provincial sales tax on that premium, because Manitoba does not levy one on default insurance, and roughly $3,150 of legal, title, inspection and adjustments. A foreign national on a work permit, insured to the identical loan-to-value at the identical minimum down payment, brings $31,545 — the same figure, because Manitoba charges a non-permanent resident nothing extra at closing. Put a conventional 20% down instead, which is roughly where lender overlays on non-permanent-resident files tend to land, and the cash needed is $97,427: no insurance premium and no premium tax, but $87,843 of down payment instead of $21,961. The monthly payment is the smaller story — $2,328 against $1,937 in principal and interest at 4.19% over 25 years. The closing-day number is the one that decides whether the purchase happens, and on a file with no non-resident tax on it the thing worth shopping is the lender overlay, which is where a work-permit buyer's real premium is hiding.