Newmarket's mortgage book is renewals, and renewals are where the money leaks
Newmarket is a low-turnover market. Families buy and stay, which means the everyday mortgage event here is not a purchase but a renewal — and renewals are the single most expensive piece of routine mortgage inertia in Canada. Your lender is required to send a renewal statement before maturity, and the offer inside it is not obliged to be the best rate that lender has, let alone the best rate available. Signing it back is the path of least resistance and frequently the most expensive one. The alternative is a switch or transfer to another lender at maturity, which moves the existing balance without increasing it. Because you are not borrowing more, a straight switch is usually a lighter transaction than a refinance, and many lenders will cover or contribute toward the legal and appraisal costs of taking your business — but it is still a new approval, so income, credit and the property are re-assessed, and the ratios are tested at the stress-test rate. That last point is the one that catches people: qualifying is not automatic simply because you have paid the mortgage for five years. Start the conversation roughly 120 days before maturity, which is the window in which most lenders will hold a rate for you, and shop it against your own lender's offer rather than instead of it.
