The same Thornhill house, two closing days
Take Thornhill's $1,350,000 average price and change nothing but the buyer's status.
More detail
A permanent resident puts $110,000 down (8.1% — 5% of the first $500,000 and 10% of the rest), finances a 4.00% default-insurance premium of $49,600 into the mortgage, and brings $141,443 to the lawyer once you add $23,475 of land transfer and registration cost, the $3,968 of provincial sales tax on that premium — which cannot be financed — and roughly $4,000 of legal, title, inspection and adjustments. A foreign national on a work permit, insured to the identical loan-to-value at the identical minimum down payment, brings $478,943 — $337,500 more, and every dollar of the difference is NRST. Put a conventional 20% down instead, which is roughly where lender overlays on non-permanent-resident files tend to land, and the cash needed is $634,975: no insurance premium and no premium tax, but $270,000 of down payment sitting beside the same $337,500 of tax. The monthly payment is the smaller story — $6,917 against $5,793 in principal and interest at 4.19% over 25 years. The closing-day number is the one that decides whether the purchase happens, and it is the reason the single most valuable thing many work-permit buyers can do is wait for permanent residence rather than shop harder for a rate.